Screen Shot 2016-05-09 at 8.03.53 AM

Why the best bad bosses are consistently mean

Research shows C-level types can't risk seeming moody to the team

A moody boss is even worse than a nasty one, according to new research from Michigan State University. “Our findings essentially show that employees are better off if their boss is a consistent jerk rather than being a loose cannon who’s fair at times and unfair at other times,” said the study’s lead author Fadel Matta in a press release.

Matta and his colleagues carried out their experiment on 160 college students. Participants were split into two rooms and given a task to complete; their heart rates were monitored throughout to gauge stress levels. Participants were told that students in the next room were supervising them; in reality the researchers were providing the feedback. A third of the study participants were always treated fairly, a third were always treated unfairly, and the last third received mixed feedback. (Examples of unfair statements included “You should be ashamed of your efforts on that last round” and “It sucks to work with an unmotivated person.”) What the researchers found was that inconsistent feedback caused higher stress levels in students than consistently unfair treatment.

Matta and his colleagues later replicated the experiment in an office setting, where researchers surveyed workers and their managers daily over a three-week period. The findings were the same: Employees with erratic bosses were more prone to stress, job dissatisfaction and emotional exhaustion than workers who received poor treatments all the time.

An explanation for this may be that people value consistency and predictability in fair treatment as much or more than fair treatment itself, according to Brent Scott, co-author of the paper. So pick a persona—grouchy or gracious—and stick with it.

This story originally appeared at CanadianBusiness.com.

(Illustration by Kagan McLeod)

See all comments Recent Comments
RICK

Make it gracious. A-holes are so tiresome.

Friday, May 13 @ 1:06 pm |

Add a comment

You must be to comment.

Brands Articles

30 Under 30 is back with a new name, new outlook

No more age limit! The New Establishment brings 30 Under 30 in a new direction, starting with media professionals.

Diageo’s ‘Crown on the House’ brings tasting home

After Johnnie Walker success, Crown Royal gets in-home mentorship

Survey says Starbucks has best holiday cup

Consumers take sides on another front of Canada's coffee war

KitchenAid embraces social for breast cancer campaign

Annual charitable campaign taps influencers and the social web for the first time

Heart & Stroke proclaims a big change

New campaign unveils first brand renovation in 60 years

Best Buy makes you feel like a kid again

The Union-built holiday campaign drops the product shots

Volkswagen bets on tech in crisis recovery

Execs want battery-powered cars, ride-sharing to 'fundamentally change' automaker

Simple strategies for analytics success

Heeding the 80-20 rule, metrics that matter and changing customer behaviors

Why IKEA is playing it up downstairs

Inside the retailer's Market Hall strategy to make more Canadians fans of its designs