6 seconds or 15? The Vine vs. Instagram smackdown

Here’s a sneak peek at our July 29 issue How much time does a brand need for social video? If you listened carefully, you could almost hear as social media managers everywhere scrambled to piece together their first Instagram video last month. Brands such as Lululemon, Urban Outfitters and Burberry started experimenting with the new […]

Here’s a sneak peek at our July 29 issue

How much time does a brand need for social video?

If you listened carefully, you could almost hear as social media managers everywhere scrambled to piece together their first Instagram video last month.

Brands such as Lululemon, Urban Outfitters and Burberry started experimenting with the new tool shortly (in Lululemon’s case less than an hour) after Facebook’s Instagram announced the 15-second video sharing option on June 20. The news has some predicting the death of Vine – Twitter’s video app that gives users just six-seconds to flex some creative muscle.

Instagram has clear advantages, the most important being the ability for users to go back and edit their work.

But what does this mean for the ad world? Should marketers favour one platform over the other? Marketing asked social and digital experts to highlight pros and cons for each.

Vine

“Vine has a laser-sharp focus: short, entertaining loops. Vine cashes in on our obsession for animated GIFs in a way that Instagram has totally ignored. This gives brands with a quirkier personality, a unique venue to share their stories.”
Scott Weisbrod, VP, strategy at Critical Mass

“When Vine launched for us it was interesting to see how creative you could be with such a limitation in terms of only having six seconds, the inability to edit, only being able to shoot from your iPhone and I think some brands took advantage of that.”
Tyler Turnbull, SVP, strategy and insight at Proximity Canada

“I think the stop motion aspect of [Vine] has been creating some of the most interesting stuff, having that built in as a feature has led to some really interesting work there. The loop is interesting.”
David Jones, VP, social media at Critical Mass

Instagram

“Instagram video has the advantage of large user base. In some ways, this makes staying the course with Instagram an easy choice for brands. Instagram encourages a continuous narrative with its 15-second, non-looping experience, giving marketers a chance to share—knowing how ironic this sounds—a more considered, longer-form story. It’s also backed by Facebook, which offers a mature advertising platform for Instagram to leverage in the future.”
– Scott Weisbrod

“Instagram is both photo and video. You’re not committing yourself to the thought process that goes into video all the time. It can be more serendipitous, whereas with Vine you need to storyboard it out and also get the creative approved way in advance. Instagram allows you to shoot, review and share.”
Ed Lee, senior director of social media at DDB Toronto

“It’s easy to shoot video, it’s tough to shoot good video. Even a 15-second video is tough to do so that it’s interesting and tells the story in a meaningful way and stands out. Instagram made everybody’s pictures a little bit better. Well see if it does the same for short-form video.”
– David Jones

For more coverage of the fast-changing social media frontier, subscribe to Marketing. Read us in print, on your iPad, or check out our Daily e-newsletters.

Media Articles

30 Under 30 is back with a new name, new outlook

No more age limit! The New Establishment brings 30 Under 30 in a new direction, starting with media professionals.

As Prime Minister, Kellie Leitch would scrap CBC

Tory leadership hopefuls are outlining their views on national broadcaster's future

‘Your Morning’ embarks on first travel partnership

Sponsored giveaway supported by social posts directed at female-skewing audience

KitchenAid embraces social for breast cancer campaign

Annual charitable campaign taps influencers and the social web for the first time

Netflix debates contributions with Canadian Heritage

Netflix remains wary of regulation as some tout 'Anne' and 'Alias Grace' partnerships

Canadians warm up to social commerce

PayPal and Ipsos research shows "Shop Now" buttons are gaining traction

Online ad exchange AppNexus cuts off Breitbart

Popular online ad exchange bans site for violating hate speech policy

Robert Jenkyn is back at Media Experts

Former Microsoft and Globe and Mail exec returns to the agency world

2016 Media Innovation Awards: The complete winners list

All the winning agencies from media's biggest night out!